Why Framers Chose Federalism Essay


When the framers of the US Constitution were creating a new system of government, they had to decide between a central government and a federal system. There were pros and cons to both approaches, but in the end, the framers decided that federalism was the best way to balance the needs of the states and the national government.

There are several reasons why the framers chose federalism. First, it allows for a division of powers between the national and state governments. This means that each level of government can focus on its own areas of expertise, without encroaching on the other’s turf.

Second, federalism provides for more local control. This is important because it allows states to experiment with different policies and solutions to problems, without having to get approval from the national government.

Third, federalism allows for a balance between the rights of the states and the national government. This is important because it ensures that neither level of government becomes too powerful.

Fourth, federalism promotes economic stability. This is because the national government can provide a backstop for state economies when they are struggling.

Overall, the framers chose federalism because they felt it was the best way to balance the needs of the states and the national government. It provides for a division of powers, more local control, a balance between state and national rights, and economic stability.

The principle of federalism divides power and authority between the national government and the state governments. In 1787, the creators of the constitution decided to establish this kind of administration over the United States. I’ll show you why the framers chose this type of governance for a variety of reasons.

First, the framers wanted to protect the rights of the minority from being overrun by the majority. In a pure democracy, it is possible for the majority to pass laws that trample on the rights of the minority. For example, in a hypothetical situation, if 51% of people in a state want to outlaw a particular religion, they could pass a law doing so.

However, under federalism, this would not be possible because each state has its own government that can pass its own laws. So, even if the majority in one state wanted to outlaw a particular religion, they would not be able to do so because other states would not have to follow that law.

Second, federalism allows for more localized control. This is possible because each state has its own government that can pass its own laws. So, if the people in a particular state want to have a law that is different from the law in another state, they can do so.

Third, federalism allows for a division of power between the national government and the state governments. This division of power prevents any one level of government from having too much power.

Fourth, federalism allows for a check on the power of the national government by the state governments. For example, if the national government were to pass a law that the state governments didn’t agree with, the state governments could refuse to follow that law.

Finally, federalism promotes competition between the different levels of government. This competition can lead to improved governance because each level of government is trying to outdo the other.

The 10th Amendment, Concurrent Powers, and Block Grants are all concerned with securing individual freedom by keeping states’ autonomy. I’ll show you how the tenth amendment, concurrent authorities, and block grants apply in the federalist system of governance. You’ll learn why the framers picked Federalism and why block grants, concurrent powers, and the tenth amendment are so important.

The tenth amendment protects states’ rights by reserving all powers not delegated to the federal government to the states or to the people. This means that the federal government can only exercise the powers specifically enumerated in the Constitution. The amendment was designed to protect state sovereignty and prevent the federal government from becoming too powerful.

Concurrent Powers are those shared by both the federal and state governments, such as taxation and law enforcement. Both governments have a role in these areas, but each one also has its own sphere of influence. This allows for a balance of power between the two levels of government and prevents either one from becoming too dominant.

Block Grants are a type of financial aid that is given to states by the federal government. They can be used for a variety of purposes, but they must be used within the guidelines set by the federal government. Block grants give states more flexibility in how they use the money, and they allow the states to tailor the programs to their own needs.

The framers of the Constitution chose federalism because they believed it would protect individual liberty. Federalism allows for a balance of power between the federal government and the states. This balance ensures that neither one becomes too powerful and that individual liberty is maintained. The concurrent powers, block grants, and tenth amendment are all essential components of federalism that help to achieve this goal.

A reason why the framers chose Federalism was because the national government was not formidable enough. The sort of government that was already in place, which was confederalism, meant that the states were too democratic. There wasn’t any leadership. The individual states were regarded as stronger than the central authority.

If the states were given more power, it would make them feel more unified and there would be less conflict between the states. Federalism was seen as a way to prevent tyranny and have a stronger national government that could get things done.

The Founders believed in limited government so that people could be free to live their lives as they saw fit. They wanted a central government that could provide for the common defense and promote the general welfare, but not one that would intrude on the rights of individuals or tell them how to live their lives. Federalism was seen as a way to balance the competing interests of the states and the national government.

In conclusion, the framers of the constitution chose federalism as the system of government for the United States because it has several advantages over other systems of government. Federalism protects the rights of the minority, allows for more localized control, promotes competition between different levels of government, and checks the power of the national government.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.